The Most Underrated Wedding Songs You Haven’t Thought Of
When it comes to wedding music, most couples gravitate toward the classics—think “At Last” by Etta James or “Perfect” by Ed Sheeran. While these beloved tracks certainly have their place, some couples want something different, something personal, something that feels like them.
If you’re in search of a wedding soundtrack that breaks away from the norm, we’ve got you covered. Here’s a handpicked list of unique and unexpected songs that will make your big day truly stand out, from the ceremony to the dance floor.
Ceremony Songs
1. “First Day of My Life” – Bright Eyes (2005)
This tender indie-folk ballad is a heartfelt choice for walking down the aisle. Its stripped-down acoustic melody and raw, emotional lyrics make it perfect for couples seeking an intimate and genuine moment.
Why It Works: The song’s lyrics capture the idea of finding a soulmate, making it a poignant choice for a ceremony.
2. “You Are the Best Thing” – Ray LaMontagne (2008)
With its soulful vibe and uplifting lyrics, this modern classic strikes the perfect balance between romantic and celebratory. Its joyful energy makes it ideal for the recessional as you exit the ceremony as a newly married couple.
Why It Works: The retro soul influence and heartfelt delivery set it apart from more traditional choices.
First Dance Songs
3. “Sea of Love” – Cat Power (2000)
Originally recorded by Phil Phillips in 1959, this hauntingly beautiful cover by Cat Power brings a modern, minimalist touch to a vintage love song. Its ethereal tone creates an intimate atmosphere for your first dance.
Why It Works: This version’s simplicity beautifully underscores the emotional connection between you and your partner, making it a perfect choice for your first dance.
4. “Stay With You” – John Legend (2004)
A less commonly played track from John Legend’s debut album, this soulful ballad is filled with promises of unwavering commitment, making it a meaningful and elegant choice for your first dance.
Why It Works: Its smooth piano accompaniment and heartfelt lyrics feel timeless and romantic.
Reception Songs
5. “Got to Get You Into My Life” – Earth, Wind & Fire (1978)
This funky cover of The Beatles’ hit is a lively, unexpected choice for your wedding reception. Its infectious energy and vibrant brass arrangement make it a standout for your dance floor.
Why It Works: This version brings a celebratory, high-energy twist to a familiar favorite.
6. “I’m Gonna Be (500 Miles)” – The Proclaimers (1988)
While often overlooked as a wedding song, this upbeat anthem can bring everyone together on the dance floor with its quirky charm and heartfelt devotion.
Why It Works: Its catchy chorus and universal appeal make it a crowd-pleaser that feels fun and meaningful.
Parent Dance Songs
7. “Wildflowers” – Tom Petty (1994)
This tender track is a lovely, understated option for a father-daughter or mother-son dance. Its poetic lyrics about love and freedom resonate beautifully in the context of a wedding.
Why It Works: The gentle acoustic instrumentation and heartfelt message make it an emotional yet uplifting choice.
8. “Forever Young” – Rod Stewart (1988)
This song’s heartfelt lyrics and anthemic melody make it a versatile choice for parent dances, symbolizing hope, love, and enduring connections.
Why It Works: The emotional depth and classic rock feel appeal to multiple generations.
Send-Off Songs
9. “You Make My Dreams” – Hall & Oates (1980)
End your night on a high note with this feel-good pop classic. Its upbeat tempo and joyful vibe ensure your guests leave with smiles on their faces.
Why It Works: The song’s infectious energy is perfect for a grand exit or final dance.
10. “Home” – Edward Sharpe & The Magnetic Zeros (2010)
This folk-pop anthem about love and belonging is a warm and unique choice for closing out your celebration. Its call-and-response vocals create an interactive moment that guests will remember.
Why It Works: The song’s theme of finding “home” in your partner resonates deeply for couples starting a new life together.
How Dennis Smith Entertainment Can Help Make Your Wedding Unique
At Dennis Smith Entertainment, we understand that every couple’s wedding day is a deeply personal celebration. That’s why we go beyond the traditional to craft a musical experience that reflects your unique story.
From curating playlists to providing live performers, our team works with you to ensure your wedding soundtrack feels authentic, memorable, and meaningful.
Our Approach to Wedding Music
Personalized Song Selections: We don't just provide a list of songs; we help you uncover hidden gems and unexpected songs that align with your preferences, ensuring every moment of your wedding feels distinct and heartfelt. Your story is unique, and your music should reflect that.
Professional Live Performers: Whether it’s an acoustic set for your ceremony, a string quartet for cocktail hour, or a dynamic party band for your reception, our performers bring songs to life with energy and artistry.
Seamless Execution: From song transitions to timing, our team ensures every piece of music flows effortlessly with your wedding’s timeline. You can trust us to handle the details so you can focus on enjoying your special day.
Celebrity Guest Appearances: Looking to surprise your guests? Dennis Smith Entertainment offers the opportunity to include celebrity performers, such as Mark McGrath of Sugar Ray or other notable artists. Imagine a well-known vocalist singing their hits during your reception or engaging with guests during a VIP meet-and-greet.
Special Touches: Looking to surprise your guests? We can incorporate unique elements like mashups, medleys, or even custom compositions to make your wedding music one of a kind.
Why It Matters
Music is more than just a background element; it’s a cornerstone of your wedding’s atmosphere. The right song at the right moment can bring guests to tears, fill the dance floor, or create an unforgettable shared experience. At Dennis Smith Entertainment, we’re passionate about making those moments resonate.
Ready to Find Your Perfect Wedding Songs?
Whether you’re drawn to hidden gems, timeless classics, or unexpected hits, Dennis Smith Entertainment is here to help you craft the perfect soundtrack for your big day. Let us handle the music while you focus on enjoying every moment.
Contact Dennis Smith Entertainment today to start designing your wedding’s unforgettable musical experience.
